Constitutional Anti-Fascism – New Review of Alexander Thiele’s ‘Rechtspopulismus und der demokratische Verfassungsstaat’

In the Portal für Politikwissenschaft, I have reviewed constitutional theorist Alexander Thiele’s new book Rechtspopulismus und der demokratische Verfassungsstaat (Right-Wing Populism and the Democratic Constitutional State, Reclam 2026).
Thiele offers a concise and accessible reminder of the normative foundations of the liberal constitutional state: democracy rests on human dignity and the equal freedom of all. This is why fundamental rights, the separation of powers and constitutional review set limits to the will of the majority. According to Thiele, right-wing populism denies this equal political freedom – for instance by invoking a “true will of the people” and homogenising concepts of the people. As a counter-strategy, Thiele proposes closing the real legitimacy gaps of democracy and makes concrete suggestions for doing so. He also appeals to conservatives to uphold democratic ethos and not to open themselves up to right-wing populist rhetoric.
I consider this reminder of the normativity of the constitutional state valuable. However, the proposed solutions remain too weak, because the analysis of causes does not reach the structural problems: unequal opportunities for participation are a question of class, the dramatic inequality of wealth is barely addressed, and the connection between the liberal-capitalist order and processes of fascisation is missing. Instead of centrist appeals, what is needed is substantial redistribution, for example through wealth and inheritance taxes, and a democratic left-wing populism.
That some of Thiele’s proposals sound somewhat like stock phrases is also due to the book’s guiding concept, right-wing populism. With it, Thiele can bring into clear focus neither the anti-constitutional character of the AfD nor the structural causes of the rise of far-right positions. The book thus falls behind the state of reflection in current debates, which work with the concepts of right-wing extremism, fascism and fascisation.
Cite and Read
Schubert, Karsten (2026): Alexander Thiele: Rechtspopulismus und der demokratische Verfassungsstaat. Ditzingen: Reclam 2026. Portal für Politikwissenschaft, 13.11.2026. https://doi.org/10.36206/REZ26.41. https://www.pw-portal.de/demokratie-und-frieden/ueberblick/alexander-thiele-rechtspopulismus-und-der-demokratische-verfassungsstaat.
Related Posts
- Gefangen in der Totalität. Daniel Loicks Gegengemeinschaften sollten den liberalen Rechtsstaat verteidigen - Neue Rezension in 'Ethik und Gesellschaft', 27. May 2025
- Special Issue: The Dissolution of the Liberal Consensus (ZfPT), 25. January 2024
- Between Conservative and Critical Epistemology – New Book Review in the Deutsche Zeitschrift für Philosophie, 3. March 2026
- Interview on far-right attacks on liberal democracy and identity politics in the Süddeutsche Zeitung, 23. September 2025
- Article in Ethics Journal on 'Democracy as an Open Form of Life', 26. July 2025
Right-Wing PopulismRight-Wing ExtremismDemocracyConstitutional StateLiberalismBook Review
312 Words
2026-11-18 07:00 +0100